TopMyGrade

GCSE/Business Studies/Edexcel

2.3.2Working with suppliers: managing stock (bar gate stock graphs, just-in-time vs just-in-case), procurement, the role of logistics, factors affecting choice of suppliers

Notes

Working with suppliers

Supplier management directly affects cost, quality and customer satisfaction. Edexcel 1BS0 covers stock management (including bar gate graphs and JIT vs JIC), procurement, logistics, and the factors a business considers when choosing suppliers.

Stock management

Bar gate stock graph

A simple chart showing stock level over time. Key features:

  • Maximum stock level — the upper line; storage capacity.
  • Reorder level — the level at which a new order is placed (factoring in lead time).
  • Minimum/buffer stock — the safety floor; running below this risks stockout.
  • Lead time — gap between placing an order and receiving it.

Stock falls steadily as units are sold/used; spikes upward each time a delivery arrives, ideally just as stock hits reorder level.

Just-in-time (JIT)

Stock arrives exactly when needed for production. Pioneered by Toyota.

  • Pros: low storage cost, less obsolete stock, fast cash conversion.
  • Cons: highly vulnerable to supplier disruption (Covid, Suez Canal blockage); requires reliable suppliers and accurate demand forecasts.

Just-in-case (JIC)

Hold buffer stock to insure against supply disruption or unexpected demand.

  • Pros: resilient, copes with shocks.
  • Cons: storage costs, working capital tied up, risk of obsolete stock.

Procurement

Procurement is the process of finding and buying goods/services from suppliers — including supplier vetting, contract negotiation, and ordering. Effective procurement reduces unit cost, ensures quality and minimises risk of disruption.

Logistics

Logistics is the management of the flow of goods from supplier → business → customer.

Components: transport, warehousing, distribution, returns. Modern logistics relies on real-time tracking, route-planning algorithms, and integration with stock systems.

Factors affecting choice of supplier

A business considers:

  • Price — unit cost; bulk discount; payment terms.
  • Quality — consistency; rejection/return rates.
  • Reliability — on-time delivery percentage.
  • Trust — long-term relationship; reputation; financial stability.
  • Location — proximity to reduce lead time and transport cost (or for ethical "buy local" reasons).
  • Ethics — child labour, environmental record, certifications (Fairtrade, B-Corp).

A business often has multiple suppliers for the same input — one primary, one backup — to avoid dependency.

Edexcel exam tip

Questions on JIT vs JIC are common. The key is to identify the risk profile of the business: high disruption risk (overseas suppliers, perishable inputs) → JIC; predictable demand and reliable local suppliers → JIT. Strong AO3 answers acknowledge that hybrid approaches (lean buffer stock) are often optimal.

AI-generated · claude-opus-4-7 · v3-edexcel-business-leaves

Practice questions

Try each before peeking at the worked solution.

  1. Question 12 marks

    Stock terms — 2-mark identify

    Edexcel 1BS0 Paper 2 style

    State two elements shown on a bar gate stock graph.

    [2 marks]

    Ask AI about this

    AI-generated · claude-opus-4-7 · v3-edexcel-business-leaves

  2. Question 26 marks

    JIT vs JIC — 6-mark analyse

    Edexcel 1BS0 Paper 2 style

    "FreshFare" is a high-end restaurant in Edinburgh that sources ingredients from local farms and overseas (e.g. Italian olive oil, French cheeses).

    Analyse whether FreshFare should use JIT or JIC stock management.

    [6 marks]

    AO1 (up to 2 marks):

    • JIT minimises storage by ordering stock to arrive when needed B1.
    • JIC holds buffer stock to insure against disruption B1.

    AO2 (up to 2 marks):

    • Local fresh ingredients (vegetables, dairy) suit JIT — short lead time and perishable B1.
    • Overseas ingredients (olive oil, cheese) face longer lead times and disruption risks (port delays, Brexit), suiting JIC B1.

    AO3 (up to 2 marks):

    • A hybrid approach is most appropriate — JIT for perishables, JIC for shelf-stable imports — minimising waste while protecting against disruption B1.
    • Pure JIT is risky given Brexit and supply-chain volatility post-2020; pure JIC ties up working capital and risks waste on perishables. Hybrid is the rational compromise B1.

    Total: 6 marks.

    Ask AI about this

    AI-generated · claude-opus-4-7 · v3-edexcel-business-leaves

  3. Question 39 marks

    Choosing a supplier — 9-mark recommend

    Edexcel 1BS0 Paper 2 style

    "GreenTote" makes reusable shopping bags. It is choosing between two cotton suppliers:

    • Supplier A (UK) — £2.10/kg, 5-day lead time, ISO-certified, but no Fairtrade.
    • Supplier B (India) — £1.20/kg, 30-day lead time, Fairtrade-certified, occasional quality issues.

    Recommend which supplier GreenTote should use. Justify your decision.

    [9 marks]

    AO1 (up to 3 marks):

    • Suppliers chosen on price, quality, reliability, ethics, location B1.
    • Lead time affects stock holding requirement B1.
    • Ethical sourcing matters increasingly to consumers B1.

    AO2 (up to 3 marks):

    • Supplier B is 43% cheaper per kg — significant cost saving on a commodity input B1.
    • 30-day lead time vs 5 days means GreenTote must hold ~6x more stock if it uses B B1.
    • Fairtrade certification supports GreenTote's brand positioning as ethical, justifying premium retail price B1.

    AO3 (up to 3 marks):

    • Quality issues with Supplier B could cause customer complaints, returns, and brand damage — the cost saving is partly offset B1.
    • Supplier A reduces working-capital tied up in stock and supports a faster, more responsive supply chain B1.
    • Justified recommendation: use Supplier A as primary AND Supplier B for a small Fairtrade-certified product line, marketed as a premium ethical range. This combines reliability with ethical positioning, captures both customer segments, and avoids over-reliance on either source. Sole-supplier dependency — especially on B with quality issues — is too risky B1.

    Total: 9 marks.

    Ask AI about this

    AI-generated · claude-opus-4-7 · v3-edexcel-business-leaves

Flashcards

2.3.2 — Working with suppliers: stock management, procurement, logistics, supplier choice

7-card SR deck for Edexcel GCSE Business — Leaves (batch 1) topic 2.3.2

7 cards · spaced repetition (SM-2)