TopMyGrade

GCSE/Geography/Edexcel

T9.1Classification of energy: renewable (solar, wind, hydro, biomass, geothermal, tidal) vs non-renewable (coal, oil, gas, nuclear); trends in global energy mix

Notes

Energy Resources

Classification of energy sources

Non-renewable (finite — will run out)

  • Fossil fuels: coal, oil, natural gas. Formed from compressed organic matter over millions of years. Combust to release energy; primary source of global GHG emissions.
  • Nuclear: uranium (fissile material) produces heat via fission → steam → turbine. No direct CO₂ emissions during operation; produces radioactive waste.

Renewable (replenished naturally)

  • Solar: photovoltaic (PV) panels convert sunlight → electricity; solar thermal heats water. Cost has fallen ~90% since 2010; now often cheaper than new fossil fuel plants.
  • Wind: onshore and offshore wind turbines. UK has Europe's largest offshore wind capacity (Hornsea One: 1.2 GW, 174 turbines off Yorkshire).
  • Hydro: dams use falling water → turbine. Oldest large-scale renewable; ~16% of global electricity. Impacts on rivers and communities.
  • Biomass: burning organic matter (wood, crop waste, biogas). Carbon-neutral if sustainably managed; but air quality issues; land use competition.
  • Geothermal: heat from Earth's interior drives steam turbines. Reliable 24/7 baseload. Limited to tectonically active areas (Iceland, Kenya, New Zealand).
  • Tidal/Wave: emerging technology; consistent and predictable (unlike wind/solar); high capital cost. Swansea Bay Tidal Lagoon proposal (Wales).

Global energy mix trends

  • In 2024, fossil fuels still supply ~80% of global primary energy.
  • Renewables growing rapidly but from a low base.
  • Natural gas replacing coal in many HICs (lower CO₂ per unit energy).
  • China installs more solar and wind than the rest of the world combined; but also builds coal plants for energy security.

Access to energy: the energy gap

Energy security means reliable, affordable, and sufficient access to energy.

Energy poverty: ~760 million people (mostly in sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia) have no electricity access; 2.4 billion rely on traditional biomass (wood, dung, charcoal) for cooking — serious health impacts from indoor air pollution.

Factors affecting energy access

FactorEffect
Physical geographyOil/gas deposits, solar irradiance, wind resource, geothermal activity
Economic developmentHICs can invest in grid infrastructure; LIDCs cannot afford imports
Political stabilityConflict disrupts energy supply (Yemen, DRC); geopolitics of pipelines
TechnologyCost of renewables falling → off-grid solar now viable in rural LIDCs
Colonial legacyMany LIDCs extract/export fossil fuels but import expensive refined products

Energy security risk: countries that depend heavily on energy imports are vulnerable to price shocks and geopolitical leverage (e.g. Europe's dependence on Russian gas → 2022 energy crisis following invasion of Ukraine).

Impacts of energy production

Fossil fuel extraction

  • Conventional oil/gas: platform leaks, pipeline spills (e.g. Niger Delta pollution — 40 years of Shell operations linked to chronic oil spills, impacting fishing communities; 5,000 oil spills since 1976).
  • Coal mining: surface (opencast) and underground. Landscape destruction; acid mine drainage; methane release.

Unconventional fossil fuels (higher environmental impact)

  • Oil sands / tar sands (Alberta, Canada): bitumen extracted from sand using hot water → very high energy and water input; tailings ponds of toxic waste; forest clearing.
  • Hydraulic fracturing (fracking) for shale gas: high-pressure fluid injected to fracture shale rock → gas released. Issues: potential groundwater contamination; surface water use (millions of litres per well); seismic activity (induced earthquakes at Blackpool, 2018 → UK imposed moratorium); methane leaks during extraction.
  • Deep-water oil drilling (Gulf of Mexico Deepwater Horizon, 2010 — 4.9 million barrels spilled; Macondo well blowout). Environmental damage to Gulf Coast for years; 11 workers killed.

Renewable energy impacts

Even renewables have environmental impacts:

  • Wind turbines: bird and bat mortality; visual impact; noise; rare earth metals in generators (mining in China/Congo).
  • Solar farms: land use; manufacturing of panels (silicon, cadmium); end-of-life disposal of panels.
  • Hydro dams: flooding of valleys and ecosystems; fish migration blocked; sedimentation; community displacement (Three Gorges Dam, China: 1.2 million displaced).
  • Biofuels: compete with food crops for land; can drive deforestation (palm oil biodiesel).

Towards a sustainable energy future

Efficiency and demand reduction

  • Building insulation: UK homes are among Europe's least efficient; retrofitting could reduce heating energy use by 50%.
  • LED lighting: 75% more efficient than incandescent bulbs.
  • Smart grids: match supply and demand in real time; reduce waste.

Low-carbon technology

  • Carbon capture and storage (CCS): captures CO₂ from power stations / industrial processes → stores underground in geological formations. Currently expensive (~£100/tonne CO₂). Sleipner field (Norway) is an example.
  • Hydrogen (green): produced by electrolysis of water using renewable electricity → CO₂-free fuel for industry, heating, transport. Currently expensive; infrastructure lacking.
  • Electric vehicles: shift transport emissions from exhaust to power plant (decarbonised if grid is clean).
  • Nuclear (new generation): small modular reactors (SMRs) proposed as flexible, low-carbon baseload. Hinkley Point C (Somerset) — new large nuclear plant under construction (delayed, over budget: £35 bn+).

Meeting future demand sustainably

  • Global energy demand will increase as populations grow and living standards rise.
  • Decarbonisation requires: rapid scaling of solar/wind, electrification of heat and transport, demand reduction, smart grids, and some baseload (nuclear or CCS gas).
  • Just Transition: must ensure LIDCs are not locked out of development by being denied fossil fuels before renewables are affordable — international climate finance (Green Climate Fund: $100 bn/year target) is key.

Edexcel B exam tip

Energy questions often use maps of global energy mix or case studies of unconventional fossil fuel extraction. "Assess the extent to which renewable energy can meet future global demand" (8 marks, L1–L3): argue for (falling costs, rapid expansion, UK's net-zero pathway) → argue against (intermittency, grid storage, energy poverty in LIDCs, scale of current fossil fuel dependency) → balanced conclusion.

AI-generated · claude-opus-4-7 · v3-edexcel-geography

Practice questions

Try each before peeking at the worked solution.

  1. Question 14 marks

    Classify energy types (4 marks)

    Distinguish between renewable and non-renewable energy sources, giving examples of each. [4 marks]

    Ask AI about this

    AI-generated · claude-opus-4-7 · v3-edexcel-geography

  2. Question 24 marks

    Impacts of unconventional fossil fuel extraction (4 marks)

    Explain the environmental and social impacts of extracting unconventional fossil fuels. [4 marks]

    Ask AI about this

    AI-generated · claude-opus-4-7 · v3-edexcel-geography

  3. Question 38 marks

    Assess renewable energy potential (8 marks)

    Assess the extent to which renewable energy sources can meet global energy demand sustainably in the future. [8 marks]

    Level mark scheme:

    LevelMarksDescriptor
    L11–3Simple statements about renewable energy; limited range of sources discussed; no assessment of their ability to meet global demand.
    L24–6Some explanation of renewable energy potential and limitations; both sides partially covered; some evidence but may lack specificity.
    L37–8Detailed, balanced assessment; specific technologies and evidence discussed; honest acknowledgement of intermittency, storage, LIDCs energy access, and scale of fossil fuel dependency; justified conclusion on the extent to which renewables can meet demand.

    Indicative content:

    • For renewables: solar cost fell ~90% since 2010 — now cheapest electricity source in history; UK Hornsea One (1.2 GW offshore wind); Denmark already generates >50% electricity from wind; solar off-grid now viable in rural LIDCs.
    • Limitations: intermittency (no sun at night, no wind in calm weather) → requires battery storage (currently expensive and resource-intensive) or long-distance grid interconnection; grid infrastructure in LIDCs too weak for rapid electrification.
    • Scale problem: renewables are growing but fossil fuels still ~80% of global energy — replacing this infrastructure by 2050 requires unprecedented investment.
    • LIDCs: 760 million without electricity; cannot afford same transition costs as HICs → international finance (Green Climate Fund) essential.
    • Conclusion: renewable energy can meet global demand sustainably BUT only with massive investment in storage, grid infrastructure, and international finance for LIDCs; transition needs to be just as well as fast — neither alone is sufficient.
    Ask AI about this

    AI-generated · claude-opus-4-7 · v3-edexcel-geography

  4. Question 42 marks

    Energy security (2 marks)

    Explain what is meant by "energy security" and why it is a concern for some countries. [2 marks]

    Ask AI about this

    AI-generated · claude-opus-4-7 · v3-edexcel-geography

Flashcards

T9.1 — Energy resources: renewable vs non-renewable, access, impacts and sustainable future

8-card SR deck for Edexcel Geography topic T9.1

8 cards · spaced repetition (SM-2)