TopMyGrade

GCSE/Psychology/AQA

P1.R.6Planning research: pilot studies, ethics (BPS code: consent, deception, withdrawal, protection, confidentiality, debriefing) and dealing with ethical issues

Notes

Before a full study, careful planning includes a pilot and consideration of ethics.

Pilot studies

A pilot study is a small-scale trial run before the main study. Purposes:

  • Check that the procedure works as intended.
  • Spot ambiguous instructions or items in a questionnaire.
  • Test that the equipment, timing and software function.
  • Estimate how long each session will take.
  • Check ethical procedures with a small group before scaling.

Finding problems in a pilot is cheaper than finding them after running 200 participants.

The BPS Code of Ethics

The British Psychological Society guides ethical practice in UK psychology. Six core principles for human participants:

  1. Informed consent. Participants must know what the study involves before agreeing. Consent must be documented; for under-16s, parental consent is required as well.
  2. Right to withdraw. Participants can leave at any time, during or after the study, without penalty, and can withdraw their data.
  3. Protection from harm. Participants must not be exposed to physical or psychological harm beyond what they would meet in everyday life. If harm is reasonably foreseeable, the study should be redesigned or abandoned.
  4. Confidentiality / anonymity. Participants' data must not identify them; codes are used in place of names and data stored securely.
  5. Deception. Should be avoided where possible; if deception is necessary (and approved by an ethics committee), participants must be debriefed afterwards.
  6. Debrief. After the study, participants are told the full purpose, given the chance to ask questions, and offered information on support if any distress arose.

Dealing with ethical issues

  • Informed consent: detailed information sheet; signed consent form; "presumptive consent" (asking similar people whether they would agree) when full disclosure would invalidate the study.
  • Withdrawal: state right to withdraw clearly at start and during the study.
  • Protection: pilot the procedure for distress; provide support contacts.
  • Confidentiality: anonymise data immediately; secure storage; aggregate reporting.
  • Deception: pre-approval by ethics committee; full debrief; option to withdraw data after debrief.

Ethics review

At UK universities, every study with human participants must be approved by an ethics committee before recruitment begins. The committee weighs the scientific value against the costs to participants and society.

Common mistakesCommon errors

  • Confusing anonymity (not collecting identifying data) with confidentiality (collecting it but keeping it secret).
  • Listing principles without saying how they would be addressed in the scenario given.
  • Forgetting that the right to withdraw extends after the study (e.g. asking that data be deleted weeks later).

AI-generated · claude-opus-4-7 · v3-deep-psychology

Practice questions

Try each before peeking at the worked solution.

  1. Question 13 marks

    Define pilot study

    What is a pilot study and why is it conducted? (3 marks)

    Ask AI about this

    AI-generated · claude-opus-4-7 · v3-deep-psychology

  2. Question 24 marks

    Six BPS principles

    Name four ethical principles from the BPS code that researchers must follow. (4 marks)

    Ask AI about this

    AI-generated · claude-opus-4-7 · v3-deep-psychology

  3. Question 34 marks

    Apply: deception

    In a study on conformity, the researcher cannot disclose the true purpose without invalidating the results. Explain how the researcher could ethically address the deception issue. (4 marks)

    Ask AI about this

    AI-generated · claude-opus-4-7 · v3-deep-psychology

  4. Question 42 marks

    Confidentiality vs anonymity

    Distinguish between confidentiality and anonymity in psychological research. (2 marks)

    Ask AI about this

    AI-generated · claude-opus-4-7 · v3-deep-psychology

  5. Question 52 marks

    Right to withdraw

    Outline two practical steps a researcher can take to protect participants' right to withdraw. (2 marks)

    Ask AI about this

    AI-generated · claude-opus-4-7 · v3-deep-psychology

Flashcards

P1.R.6 — Planning research: pilot studies and ethics

8-card SR deck for AQA GCSE Psychology P1.R.6

8 cards · spaced repetition (SM-2)